With both the Canadiens and Maple Leafs being well established, rookie cards were scarce. Montreal was at the end of a five consecutive year run being Stanley Cup champions. The rookie card of Ralph Backstrom of the Habs is one of two significant RCs in the set, along with Bob Nevin of the Maple Leafs.
The most valuable hockey cards in the 1958-59 Parkhurst set belong to Jacques Plante, Maurice Richard, Henri Richard, Frank Mahovlich, Jean Beliveau, Johnny Bower and Tim Horton. The set also featured Toe Blake and Billy Reay, head coaches of the two teams. The set was filled out with several In Action cards.
Uncorrected errors include spelling errors on the Johnny Bower and Allan Stanley cards.