Important rookie cards are limited to the unrelated Gilles Tremblay and J.C. Tremblay, along with Bobby Rousseau, all of the Montreal Canadiens. The most valuable hockey cards belong to Gordie Howe, Jacques Plante, Dave Keon and Tim Horton.
| Number | Player |
|
1
|
Billy Harris |
| 2 | Dick Duff  |
| 3 | Bob Baun |
| 4 | Frank Mahovlich |
| 5 | Leonard “Red” Kelly |
| 6 | Ron Stewart |
| 7 | Tim Horton |
| 8 | Carl Brewer |
| 9 | Allan Stanley |
| 10 | Bob Nevin |
| 11 | Bob Pulford |
| 12 | Ed Litzenberger |
| 13 | George Armstrong |
| 14 | Eddie Shack |
| 15 | Dave Keon |
| 16 | Johnny Bower |
| 17 | Larry Hillman |
| 18 | Frank Mahovlich |
| 19 | Hank Bassen RC |
| 20 | Gerry Odrowski RC |
| 21 | Norm Ullman |
| 22 | Vic Stasiuk |
| 23 | Bruce MacGregor RC |
| 24 | Claude LaForge |
| 25 | Bill Gadsby |
| 26 | Leo Labine |
| 27 | Val Fonteyne |
| 28 | Howie Glover |
| 29 | Marc Boileau RC |
| 30 | Gordie Howe |
| 31 | Gordie Howe |
| 32 | Alex Delvecchio |
| 33 | Marcel Pronovost |
| 34 | Sid Abel [Coach] |
| 35 | Len Lunde |
| 36 | Warren Godfrey |
| 37 | Phil Goyette |
| 38 | Henri Richard |
| 39 | Jean Beliveau |
| 40 | Bill Hicke |
| 41 | Claude Provost |
| 42 | Dickie Moore |
| 43 | Don Marshall |
| 44 | Ralph Backstrom |
| 45 | Marcel Bonin |
| 46 | Gilles Tremblay RC |
| 47 | Bobby Rousseau RC |
| 48 | Bernie “Boom-Boom” Geoffrion |
| 49 | Jacques Plante |
| 50 | Tom Johnson |
| 51 | Jean-Guy Talbot |
| 52 | Lou Fontinato |
| 53 | Bernie “Boom-Boom” Geoffrion |
| 54 | J.C. Tremblay RC |
| NON | Tally Game Card |
